mercredi 22 juin 2011

Lybie: Obama critiqué par ses alliés.


La légitimité de l'intervention en Lybie est soulevée une fois de plus, cette fois par des alliés...

"Critics across the ideological spectrum have criticized President Obama for overruling a determination by Attorney General Eric Holder and the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel that continued action in Libya is unlawful. But some of the White House's natural allies in the liberal legal community -- including those close to the administration -- are troubled by a separate, and in some ways more fundamental, part of this story.

In addition to overruling the OLC -- the Justice Department office tasked with establishing the bounds of lawful conduct for the executive branch -- the Obama administration also circumvented the basic process administrations typically follow in assuring its policies are legal.

"Here, if what's being reported is accurate, the White House counsel played the role of OLC, by soliciting the views of different agencies," said Dawn Johnsen, in an interview. "That's the big problem here. You're more likely to end up with bad legal decisions when you deviate from that process."

Johnsen was President Obama's first pick to head OLC in 2009. But her nomination stalled for months, and was eventually withdrawn, in the face of unanimous opposition and flagging White House support. She was a senior Justice Department official for five years during the Clinton administration, which included a stint as acting OLC head. She notes that typically, OLC will solicit the views of interested agencies, and offer the President its best interpretation of the law. In the case of Libya, the White House essentially treated the OLC as one interested agency among many, and came to its own determination based on an evaluation of competing views, according to the New York Times' original story about the controversy. That story has gone unrefuted by the White House.

"Up until this point the Obama administration has effectively protected U.S. interests through entirely appropriate and lawful means - respecting the rule of law, Congress, OLC's role - so I hope and expect this deviation from traditional processes will prove to be an aberration and the administration will get back to that framework," Johnsen added."

Aucun commentaire:

Enregistrer un commentaire

Les Tours de Laliberté migrent: rejoignez-moi sur le site du Journal de Québec et du Journal de Montréal

Depuis un certain temps je me demandais comment faire évoluer mon petit carnet web. La réponse m'est parvenue par le biais d'u...