Caricatures "strip search" et Cour suprême

Caricature de JIMMY MARGULIES, THE RECORD OF HACKENSACK, NJ

Caricature de KIRK WALTERS, TOLEDO BLADE

Caricature de PAT BAGLEY, SALT LAKE TRIBUNE 

 Je vous laisse cette série de caricatures parues après une décision de la Cour suprême. Décision, cinq contre quatre, qui laisse entrevoir la division au sein du plus haut tribunal.

 "Jailers may perform invasive strip searches on people arrested even for minor offenses, an ideologically divided Supreme Court ruled Monday, the conservative majority declaring that security trumps privacy in an often dangerous environment.

In a 5-4 decision, the court ruled against a New Jersey man who was strip searched in two county jails following his arrest on a warrant for an unpaid fine that he had, in reality, paid.

The decision resolved a conflict among lower courts about how to balance security and privacy. Prior to the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks, lower courts generally prohibited routine strip searches for minor offenses. In recent years, however, courts have allowed jailers more discretion to maintain security, and the high court ruling ratified those decisions.

 In this case, Albert Florence’s nightmare began when the sport utility vehicle driven by his pregnant wife was pulled over for speeding. He was a passenger; his 4-year-old son was in the backseat.

Justice Anthony Kennedy said the circumstances of the arrest were of little importance. Instead, Kennedy said, Florence’s entry into the general jail population gave guards the authorization to force him to strip naked and expose his mouth, nose, ears and genitals to a visual search in case he was hiding anything.

“Courts must defer to the judgment of correctional officials unless the record contains substantial evidence showing their policies are an unnecessary or unjustified response to problems of jail security,” Kennedy said."

 http://www.suntimes.com/news/nation/11682964-418/supreme-court-strip-searches-ok.html